My Pretty by Madeline Fay – A Book Review

Posted February 17, 2020 by Booksandblurbs in Fantasy, Reverse Harem, Reviews / 0 Comments

My Pretty (Mischief Matchmakers #1) by Madeline Fay - A Book Review #BookReview #Oz #FastBurn #RH #MischiefMatchmakers #KindleUnlimited #KU

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

My Pretty

(Mischief Matchmakers)

by Madeline Fay
My rating: 3.5 of 5 stars

Fast Burn, Fantasy RH, HEA
Available on Kindle and Kindle Unlimited

Down & Dirty

We all know the story of Dorthy and the Wicked Witch… or do we? This is a Fast Burn, Reverse Harem take on the famous tale. Free on Kindle Unlimited.

What is it about?

(Blurb from GoodReads)

I’m wicked, bad to the bone, and a tad green.

All I ever wanted was to have normal witchy life but Dorothy ruined it all for me.

She turned my people against me, saying I was an wicked, evil witch. I mean if that’s what the people think, then fine that’s what they’ll get. I ride around on my broom, terrorizing the citizens and stealing candy from children.

Three handsome men drop into our world from a tornado that sweeps through the village and of course I’m somehow to blame. I didn’t cause this destruction… and definitely didn’t bring a strip club along for the ride.

Dorothy sends them after me and promises a way for them to get back home as long as they get rid of the Wicked Witch of the East.

Disguising myself as a damsel in distress with my green face hiding, I lead them along the yellow brick road to Emerald city.

I’ll get those pretty men before they can get me.


This is a Fast Burn Reverse Harem Romance which features alternative romantic dynamics, sexual scenes and a Heroine that does not have to choose between her love interests. Mature readers only.

The Collection

The Mischief Matchmakers is a collection of Villain Retellings penned by your favorite PNR, UF and RH authors. Want to know more? Here is their FaceBook group! Mischief Matchmakers Misfits

Thoughts on My Pretty

Alright, this was actually a pretty fun ride. It’s silly, effervescent and totally insane, but it’s also humorous, hot and cheeky.

There isn’t much substance to it, and the writing comes across as stilted occasionally, while other points are downright amateurish…. but it’s still worth a read, despite the flaws. If nothing else, you’ll laugh my pretties.

Favorite Lines

He must’ve sent Tits McGee over here… her stripper name is really Tits McGee. (18%)
My stomach is quivering with nerves, I’m second guessing myself. What if I can’t control myself and accidentally fall, and I somehow slip onto one of their cocks? I only have so much control. (37%)
Can’t a witch have a few moments alone so she can pout and plot evil shit? (76%)


  • Funny!!
  • Twisted land Andy take on the familiar story.
  • Love East.
  • Glinda…. I died.


  • Writing was rough and fairly choppy.
  • Shatter her heart? That was never explained.
  • Uncle Oz… I’m So confused.


First Person, Multiple POV

Ending Type




Romantic Dynamic


Character Age Range


My Final Verdict on My Pretty

3.5 out of 5 Stars

I had issues with the writing style, but there is still something compelling about this novel – an urge to find out what happens, and why. It’s funny, hot and perfectly silly. Free on Kindle Unlimited.

Published January 10th, 2020
179 Pages

If you enjoyed this review of My Pretty, please consider checking out a few of my other articles.


Your Turn

What are you reading today? Have you read this book yet? What about other books by Madeline Fay? Leave a comment, I would love to talk!


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply